Archive for the ‘The Craft of Writing’ Category

Critiquing A Friend’s Writing

Like anyone, I needed validation as a writer when I was just getting started. So naturally I was disappointed when I was turned down by acquaintances who were published authors when I asked if they would look over my work to give me some feedback. Therefore, when the opportunity came up for me to read and critique my friend Dylan’s epic fantasy “Dawn of Ragnorok” I made sure not to disappoint. I feel it’s important to not only give constructive, positive feedback, but honest and helpful feed back while bringing a smile to their face. The letter below, in my opinion, is how it should be done. If you’re an accomplished writer, and a friend asks for a little feedback, take the time and do for them what you naturally would have liked done for you:

Dylan,

I liked your story. It’s very “Robert E. Howard.” You have a gift for writing and have your own personal style, your own “stamp,” on your work. You have a talent for packing profound meaning into short phrases that are uniquely your own.

You have three dimensional characters that readers care about. That’s difficult for new writers to do. You also have a very realistic backdrop that comes with it’s own “history.” Again this is a difficult task to accomplish for those getting started. You’ve made a character out of the landscape through great attention to detail and vivid description.

That’s the good news. The bad news is that we all need editors. You, me, and professional writers. Even people whose day job is editing need their book edited by others.

Your grammar and punctuation are very well done, which will put you ahead of the game (and save you some $$) when it comes editing time. As far as that other thing editors are good for (giving advice/suggestions on making changes to plot/story), I personally don’t see any obvious areas that need work. I’m certain there have to be, but they don’t leap out at me. Your story seems well rounded.

That being said, the areas I see that could use professional guidance include (and keep in mind, these are just my opinions):

1. Shorten the battle scenes and/or reduce the number of them. They are too long and too detailed. I found myself skipping ahead to where the story picks up. Also, consider thinking of another way of conveying the message or carry the scene without yet another battle peppered with testosterone fueled dialogue…

2. …which brings me to the next point. Be careful with your adjectives. On occasion your sentences get bogged down with excessive, over-the-top descriptors that would make the most seasoned of Conan comic readers cringe. Yes, there is a fine line between writing to genre and crossing over into cheezy. You, my friend, dance with the devil on the razor’s fine edge that is the city limits of Cheezville.

3. You have the same affliction as I and many from our generation. I think in our youth we read books giving us the impression it was okay to habitually use the word “smirk.” An editor used to say of my writing, “There’s a lot of smirking going on here,” and would shake her head sadly. You, however, take it to a whole new level. There were pages I felt like I was watching an episode of the “Smurfs.” Except instead of saying “smurf” every other word, “smirk” was used: “Hey Papa Smirk, you better get smirking!” Smirkity, smirk, smirk! Again, think of alternative words or means of conveying a person’s expression. This is an opportunity to employ the literary device of “show, don’t tell.”

4. A good editor will show you the proper and effective use of ellipses, because…the…only…characters that can…get away…with talking…like this are…Captain Kirk…and William Shatner.

And that’s about all I have to say, for what it’s worth. I did enjoy the story and I hope you choose to do something with your epic tale. Your options these days are many and varied and I wish you the best of luck!

Sincerely,

Adam Copeland

From the Synopsis to The Pitch: Promoting Your Writing

If you write, chances are you do it for one reason: To share your writing with others. Few, if any of us, write something just so that we can stick it in a drawer never to be seen again. We aspire to be story tellers on the grandest of scales. The Holy Grail of story telling is to publish so we can reach a world wide audience. To achieve that goal, we must do many things. From me, to you, to Stephen King we are obligated to jump through many hoops to promote our stories. One of the most common hoops is to simply explain our story to whomever will listen.

For example: You’re at a cocktail party and someone approaches you, saying, “I heard you wrote something. Tell me about it.” You’re being asked for a brief over view. A summary…a synopsis. Which is precisely the same thing a publisher or agent will ask when you approach them for representation. It is also what a bookstore owner or manager will ask when, as a self published author, you inquire if they will sell your book on their shelves. They first need to know what it’s about, and briefly.

If you can’t give them a memorable synopsis, you won’t get very far. It’s also important to realize there are different kinds of summaries to give depending on who you are addressing. A publisher or agent will eventually want to know the entire plot to determine marketability. An individual or bookstore, however, doesn’t want to know the ending, they just want to be intrigued enough to consider purchasing. Regardless of your audience, your summary must start out the same: With an attention grabbing line or phrase somewhere in your introduction that hooks the audience into learning more.

“Hook” is the appropriate literary term for this device. An entire book could be written on the topic of hooks alone. In fact, there is a literary agent who devoted a portion of her blog to hooks and invited readers to participate in a “best hook” competition. She no longer blogs but you can learn much by reading her archive at http://misssnark.blogspot.com.

For a publisher or agent the hook will figure prominently in your query letter, which is a single page document that introduces yourself and your story while seeking representation. Once you’ve grabbed their attention, the rest of your synopsis should seal the deal and make them take the next step. They will either ask for a full blown synopsis, an outline, sample chapters, or all the above.

As mentioned, an individual or bookstore will not ask for that much information. Their summary will be more succinct as will be their hook which will be more like the tag line you hear during a movie trailer or see on a poster. They should be motivated to buy your book immediately (or at least tell others about it, effectively becoming your viral marketing).  A summary given to this audience is called “The Pitch” (as in sales pitch, because that is essentially what it is). You want it long enough to give all the intriguing details, but short enough that you don’t lose their attention. It is very similar to what job seekers and self-promoters call an “Elevator Speech.” It’s just long enough to sell yourself while you have a potential employer or client trapped with you in an elevator.

If I were trapped with you in an elevator, my pitch might sound like this:

Every fairy tale has a grain of truth to it. If you could go back in time and see the actual event that inspired a fairy tale chances are, because people are as complex as they are, it would be far more interesting than the resulting childhood fantasy. That is what I had in mind when I wrote my novel ‘Echoes of Avalon’—a fairy tale for grown ups. It starts out in Medieval history as Sir Patrick, an Irish knight returns from the First Crusade in the Holy Lands. He’s lost his faith in people and God and is haunted by an apparition that follows him, pointing accusingly. In this state a stranger finds him and offers a new beginning as a knight protector on the fabled Isle of Avalon. Skeptical, but with few options, Patrick takes the offer. From here the story slips into the realm of fantasy as Patrick is introduced to ghost, goblins, and talking wolves on an island harboring a secret academy filled with the youth of the world’s nobility. It is here Patrick is tempted to believe again…and fall in love. That is until the ultimate villain arrives with sinister plans for the island, and the woman in Patrick’s life. Patrick soon learns that before he can battle monsters, he must first defeat his demons.

That clocks in just under a minute. Plenty of time for an elevator and it won’t lose anyone’s attention over coffee or cocktails.

It’s not enough to write a great story. You have to share it by first promoting it. The most fundamental task of promoting is simply giving your listener an intriguing summary. Hone your pitch. Craft your synopsis. It’s worth it.

Foreshadowing: Adding Flavor To Your Writing

Writing is about communication. Communication is about expression…and entertainment. Even when communication is merely about the transfer of information it is still about entertainment. Human beings are complex and deep thinking creatures who need to be intellectually stimulated. That is why as a writer you should use various techniques throughout your work to stimulate the mind. You should add seasoning to your dishes to give them flavor. One of these techniques is to add a little mystery to your creation. Because as a species, we love mysteries, riddles, crossword puzzles and episodes of “Lost.” The only thing we love more than solving mysteries is finding mysteries to solve.

So how do you add a little mystery to your story that is not a mystery? How do you add a little drama to your story that is not a drama? You use foreshadowing.

A shadow precedes you and announces your arrival. Similarly, the literary device of foreshadowing announces events before they happen. Sometimes right away, sometimes much later in the story. It drops hints of things to come. It is in effect teasing the reader. Why tease your readers? Because they want to fulfill that human need for stimulation. They want to solve the mystery, and to solve a mystery you need clues. That is what foreshadowing provides: Clues.  Every bit of information an episode of foreshadowing provides brings them closer to finding the answer. They want to test their intellectual prowess and arrive at the answer before others do. As a writer, you want to keep the reader hooked and coming back for more, or better yet, not able to put your writing down in the first place.

Foreshadowing can come as a statement made by a character, it can be imagery, or it can be an entire scene that portends things to come.

Though everybody may like to have their curiosity piqued by a mystery, not everybody likes to be brutally teased. To use food seasoning again as analogy, not everyone likes the same amount of spice on their food. Too much foreshadowing may leave your story vague, ambiguous, and cluttered with seemingly meaningless information that only serves to confuse. Too little and you may as well be reading the back of a carton of milk for entertainment.

Therefore, there is a range involving the different types of foreshadowing that can be either explicit or implicit, direct or subtle. There is a form of foreshadowing for every palate.

Shakespeare was excellent at using foreshadowing that was straightforward, but nonetheless engaging. The title character in Macbeth states, “By the pricking of my thumbs, something wicked this way comes,” which is not very subtle, but we are still quoting that line to this day. Entire books and movies have been titled after it. Similarly, in Julius Caesar the soothsayer tells Caesar, “Beware the Ides of March!” Again, not very subtle, but memorable. Direct foreshadowing like this can be made even more interesting by wrapping it in layers of poetry. In The Old Testament the prophet Nathan plainly declares to King David, “Because you have sinned and have offended the Lord your God, the sword shall never leave your house.” Nathan straightforward tells David that from now on you will have a whole lot of family problems, but uses poetic imagery to do so.

To get the most out of foreshadowing, however, one should employ the full power of mystery. When a scene is subtle enough that it leaves you scratching your head, but then gives you that “ah-ha” or “light bulb” moment later on…that is magic. The Bible has plenty of these moments as well. After scourging Jesus, the centurions go to mock him by wrapping him in a purple robe and crowning him with thorns. Little do they know they are foreshadowing the eventual crowning glory of Jesus.

Take foreshadowing even deeper and the imagery and prophetic utterances become open to interpretation and even debate…which is itself entertaining. Well, stimulating in any case. The Book of Revelation is an entire work of foreshadowing that boggles the mind. In Lord of the Flies, a pig’s head is impaled on a stick which subsequently becomes covered with flies, leaving to discussion just what is implied. The very title of that literary classic foreshadows what lies within its pages.

There is no question you should add flavor to your writing. If you want to entertain, stimulate, or just plain tease your readers, spice your creation with foreshadowing. The only question is: How spicy do you like it?

Return top